My lifelong friend John, who’s a professor of engineering at a Northeastern liberal arts college, and increasingly irrational, sent the following note last night to a very small mailinglist we both participate in…
I just watched the final installment of Ken Burns’ documentary on the dust bowl. I highly recommend it. Some amazing imagery, sometimes of hell, and amazing stories of human perseverance and toughness. Coincidentally a good lesson in negatives of capitalism, and the damage shortsighted, selfish profiteers can cause, and the need for government and regulations.
FDR really saved the day by instituting a national farming science program, with a really smart expert in charge, who over a couple of years in the middle of the decade succeeded in getting about 50% of the land terrace farmed, and planted with grass, etc. And the WPA saved a lot of people from starvation. My father, a lifelong republican, used to complain about his father, a very hard working, conservative fellow of few words who raised 11 children during the depression, dirt poor, always voting democrat: I remember my grandfather saying once “FDR saved us. You don’t know what it was like.” This documentary touches on that, but mainly focuses on the dust bowl.
I sent this reply…
An extended allegory and a link…
You’re minding your own business, struggling up a steep hill, when an enormously rich man in a brand new 1932 Packard runs you off the road into a deep ravine alongside the hill. You’re pretty banged up, but you’re alive, and as you climb out from underneath your crushed Model T, you hear the plummy voice of the rich man calling faintly from the top of the cliff, counseling you to stay strong while he goes for help.
“Welp,” you say to yourself, “It could be worse, this rich fellow can at least fetch an ambulance to take me and the missus and the kids to the hospital.”
But, then, the next thing you know, this rich man — so well intentioned, but so inept — gets into his Packard, revs the engine, and backs the car straight into a pine tree, which topples over and starts an avalanche of boulders down into the ravine. One of the rocks knocks you into the swollen river below, while another lands on top of your flivver, breaking your wife’s leg, and leaving your young son, Johnny, senseless.
Again, from the top of the ravine, comes the calm, upper-class voice of the rich man, telling you to not take counsel of your fears, that indeed, fear is the worst of all possible emotions. And while you agree that heedless fear is a terrible thing, you also think that a little panic might not be unwarranted, seeing as how your wife has a compound fracture, Johnny is laying half under a boulder, and you’re clinging to an exposed tree root in a raging mountain river.
And while the rich man talks and talks, the shadows are starting to get longer as the sun crawls across the sky
You shout up to the rich man, asking him to please get help. He says it’s on the way, that in fact happy days are right around the corner. But, you’re beginning to suspect that this fellow doesn’ t know what he’s talking about, because all you can hear from the top of the cliff is the sound of the rich man and the passengers in his car arguing about how to get the car out of the ditch and running again. It’s clear to you, an ordinary working man, that none of them have any mechanical experience. And while they argue, and push on the car from various angles, and bang at it angrily with tire irons, more boulders are dislodged and roll into the ravine.
As the sun sets, the soothing voice of the rich man continues to reassure you that help is on the way, although as far as you can tell neither he, nor his passengers have made any effort to walk the two miles back to town, preferring more impractical solutions like trying to build a hot air rescue balloon from the convertible’s canvas top.
Finally, close to midnight, as you’re just about to let go of your root and sink peacefully into the arms of a watery death, a large military convoy comes upon the scene and immediately sets to work rescuing you and your family.
You’re saved!
In later years, sitting around the fire in your rocking chairs, your son Johnny, who spent much of the ordeal lying under a boulder, fading in and out of consciousness, loves to go on and on about how the rich man “saved you”, and how he remembers the calm voice of the rich man keeping your spirits up as you suffered.
In fact, you’ve heard it so often that you and your wife just give each other a sort of silent sideways look, one that says, “that boy Johnny just ain’t been right since they got that boulder off of his head.“
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012 – 11-18/2013-looks-a-lot-like-1937-in-four-fearsome-ways.html
